Skip to main content

Advanced Search

Advanced Search

Current Filters

Filter your query

Categories

Publication Types

Other

Area of Focus
Topics
Date Range
to

Area of Focus

Improving Health Care Quality

Surveys

/

When Costs Are a Barrier to Getting Health Care: Reports from Older Adults in the United States and Other High-Income Countries

Findings from the 2021 International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults

Elderly man in mask walks down city sidewalk

An elderly man walks down the street wearing a mask on August 25, 2020, in New York City. Older Americans pay more for health care and are more likely to not get care for cost-related reasons than older people in other high-income countries. Photo: Andrew Lichtenstein/ Corbis via Getty Images

An elderly man walks down the street wearing a mask on August 25, 2020, in New York City. Older Americans pay more for health care and are more likely to not get care for cost-related reasons than older people in other high-income countries. Photo: Andrew Lichtenstein/ Corbis via Getty Images

Abstract

  • Issue: Unlike older adults in other high-income countries, those in the United States face significant financial barriers to getting health care, despite Medicare’s universal coverage. These barriers may affect use of health services as well as health outcomes.
  • Goal: To compare the out-of-pocket spending and care-seeking experiences of older Americans with those of older adults in 10 other high-income countries.
  • Methods: Analysis of findings from the Commonwealth Fund’s 2021 International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults.
  • Key Findings: One-fifth of older Americans spent more than $2,000 out of pocket on health care in the past year. Only a small share of older adults in most of the other surveyed countries had such high out-of-pocket health costs. Similarly, a higher share of older Americans reported forgoing health care because of costs. Rates of skipping dental care because of costs were similar for older adults in nations that do not offer coverage of such services, including the U.S.
  • Conclusions: Older Americans pay more for health care and are more likely to not get care for cost-related reasons than people in other high-income countries. Affordability remains a concern and should continue to be a focus of research and policy.

Introduction

Medicare’s genesis was in response to crisis: before the program existed, 48 percent of Americans age 65 and older were uninsured and 56 percent paid their health care expenses fully out of pocket.1 The sick, elderly, and disabled were at risk of impoverishment simply by getting basic health care. Medicare helped close this gap by covering the costs of medical care for older adults, as well as younger people with disabilities, providing a vulnerable population with significant financial and health security.

Despite the financial protections Medicare offers to seniors, the program leaves many older adults exposed to high health care costs. Medicare has significant cost-sharing requirements, including deductibles and, for people in the traditional program, coinsurance with no limit on out-of-pocket spending. Services that many older adults and people with disabilities often need, including long-term care, vision, hearing, and dental services, are not covered under traditional Medicare.

By comparing Medicare to other universal coverage programs in high-income countries, we can evaluate how the gaps in coverage are affecting spending and health outcomes. This issue brief examines out-of-pocket spending and the extent to which health care costs are an impediment to care for people age 65 and older in the United States and other high-income nations. While the survey asked about health care use during the COVID-19 pandemic, this analysis focuses on costs as an impediment to health care that was unrelated to the pandemic. The COVID-19 pandemic may have nonetheless influenced older adults’ survey responses and the scope of care they deemed to be necessary. The analysis relies on data from the Commonwealth Fund’s 2021 International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults, conducted between March and June of 2021. The survey included 18,477 community-dwelling adults age 65 and older in the U.S. and 10 other high-income countries.2

The Barrier Posed by High Out-of-Pocket Costs

What people pay out of pocket offers a window into how affordable health care is for older adults, many of whom live on fixed incomes and face financial challenges paying for care. In many high-income countries with national health insurance, older adults pay 5 percent of their income, or less, on health care costs. But in Australia, the United States, and Switzerland, older adults spend larger shares of their income on health care (Exhibit 1).3 While part of the difference in higher out-of-pocket spending in countries like Switzerland may be attributable to high average incomes, it also may be linked to needed services that are not covered by the health insurance system.

Jacobson_when_costs_are_barrier_2021_intl_survey_older_adults_Exhibit_01

Health Care Postponed or Skipped Because of Costs

If out-of-pocket costs for health care services are not affordable, some older adults will postpone nonurgent care or forgo it entirely. Not receiving timely care can worsen health conditions, delay diagnoses, lead to poorer health outcomes, and increase overall health care spending.4

Overall, relatively few people across the countries postponed or skipped care because of costs. Compared to older adults in other high-income countries, a larger share of those surveyed in the United States — about one in 12 — postponed or did not seek a consultation about their medical problem or get a recommended medical test, treatment, or follow-up examination (Exhibit 2). In countries like Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, and Sweden, no more than 2 percent of older adults said they skipped medical services because of the cost. While high out-of-pocket costs are more common in Switzerland than the U.S., and as common in Australia, U.S. adults age 65 and older were more likely to skip or postpone needed care.

Jacobson_when_costs_are_barrier_2021_intl_survey_older_adults_Exhibit_02

Similarly, rates of skipping a dose of medication or not filling a prescription for cost reasons were more than twice as high among Americans age 65 and older than among older adults in other high-income countries (Exhibit 3). In most countries, fewer than 2 percent of older adults reported forgoing prescription medication, whereas 9 percent in the U.S. reported doing so.

Jacobson_when_costs_are_barrier_2021_intl_survey_older_adults_Exhibit_03

Dental Care: Many Older Adults Postpone or Forgo Dental Visits for Cost Reasons

Dental care is a service that many countries either carve out separately from medical coverage or do not cover at all — despite ample evidence demonstrating the connection between oral health and physical health.5 In the United States, Medicare generally does not pay for dental services.6 Beneficiaries must pay the full amount for routine cleanings, fillings, exams, and other oral health services.

Other countries that provide medical coverage for all their citizens, including Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and Switzerland, do not pay for adult dental care. Some countries, such as Sweden, subsidize dental care, with the patient paying the bulk of the costs. In the Netherlands, it is not covered by national insurance, but the government regulates dental provider rates. In Germany, public insurance fully covers preventive care but only partly covers restorative dental care, so most people with public coverage buy supplemental dental insurance.

About one of six (16%) adults age 65 and older in the U.S. did not visit a dentist in the previous year because of the cost (Exhibit 4). A similar percentage in Australia, Canada, and New Zealand did the same — and none of these countries cover adult dental care. In other countries with more generous dental coverage, such as Germany and the Netherlands, only a small share of older adults did not pursue dental care for cost reasons.

Jacobson_when_costs_are_barrier_2021_intl_survey_older_adults_Exhibit_04

Policy Implications

Overall, our analysis shows that the affordability of health care remains a concern for older adults and is leading American seniors to forgo care. Survey data show that older Americans pay more for health care and are more likely to postpone or skip care because of the cost than people in other high-income countries. Countries where more comprehensive coverage is available have fewer people skipping or missing care. Dental care illustrates the key role coverage plays in access to care: in those countries that carve out dental care from medical coverage, or fail to cover it at all, many people avoid getting their oral health needs addressed.

Care that is postponed or never received could have cost implications for Medicare. Evidence shows that forgoing health care is associated with poor health outcomes and increased risk of hospitalization.7 The COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S. likely exacerbated this disruption in access to care. Similarly, oral health plays a key role in overall well-being, and preventive dental exams can be an important factor in early detection of diseases like cancer.8

Congress is currently considering legislation that would add dental, vision, and hearing coverage to traditional Medicare. This change could lead to an increase in U.S. older adults visiting the dentist.

How We Conducted This Study

The 2021 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults was conducted from March 1 to June 14, 2021, by SSRS, a U.S. survey research firm, and contractors in the other countries. The survey was administered to a nationally representative sample of adults age 65 and older in Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom and of adults age 60 and older in the United States.

A total of 18,477 interviews of adults age 65 and older were completed for the 2021 survey. The full U.S. sample included 360 adults ages 60–64 or who reported being older than age 60 but did not give an exact age. These responses were not included in this analysis. Final country samples (age 65 and older) ranged from 500 to 4,332. Interviews were completed either online or using computer-assisted telephone interviews.

In Australia, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, the United Kingdom, and the United States, samples were generated using probability-based overlapping landline and mobile phone sampling designs. Both mobile and landline telephone numbers were included to improve representativeness. The sample in Canada was generated using a probability-based landline-only sampling design. Standard within-household selection procedures were used to increase the likelihood of reaching an eligible respondent for landline samples.

In Germany, respondents were randomly selected from a public list of phone numbers, landline as well as mobile phones, flagged as belonging to households with at least one adult age 65 or older. In Norway, respondents were randomly selected from a listed registry, and interviews were completed via landline and mobile phones. In Sweden and Switzerland, respondents were selected via nationwide population registries, recruited via postal mail, and invited to participate in an online or phone version of the survey.

A common questionnaire was developed, translated, adapted, and adjusted for country-specific wording as needed. Interviewers were trained to conduct interviews using a standardized protocol. Response rates varied from 7.2 percent in the United Kingdom to 47.7 percent in Switzerland.

International partners joined with the Commonwealth Fund to sponsor surveys, and some countries supported the use of expanded samples to enable within-country analyses. Data were weighted to ensure that the final outcome was representative of the adult population in each country. Weighting procedures considered the sample design, probability of selection, and systematic nonresponse across known population parameters including region, sex, age, education, and other demographic characteristics deemed consistent with standards for each country. In the U.S., the weighted variables also included race and ethnicity.

The margin of sample error for the 2021 International Health Policy Survey of Older Adults was approximately +/– 2 percent for Canada and Sweden; +/– 3 percent for France, Germany, Switzerland, and the United States; +/– 4 percent for the Netherlands and the United Kingdom; +/– 5 percent for Australia and New Zealand; and +/– 6 percent for Norway, all at the 95 percent confidence interval.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Robyn Rapoport, Sarah Glancey, Rob Manley, and Christian Kline of SSRS, as well as Chris Hollander, Jen Wilson, Paul Frame, David Blumenthal, Melinda Abrams, and Eric Schneider of the Commonwealth Fund.

NOTES

  1. Karen Davis, Cathy Schoen, and Farhan Bandeali, Medicare: 50 Years of Ensuring Coverage and Care (Commonwealth Fund, Apr. 2015).
  2. We used two questions to categorize U.S. respondents as having either Medicare Advantage or traditional Medicare. A total of 1,487 respondents indicated they have Medicare coverage; 812 said that they receive their Medicare benefits through a Medicare Advantage plan; and the remaining 675 respondents were categorized as having traditional Medicare.
  3. Robin Osborn et al., “Older Americans Were Sicker and Faced More Financial Barriers to Health Care Than Counterparts in Other Countries,” Health Affairs 36, no. 12 (Dec. 2017): 2123–32.
  4. Timothy P. Hanna et al., “Mortality Due to Cancer Treatment Delay: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis,” BMJ 371, m4087, published online Nov. 4, 2020; Alexander Thomas et al., “Forgone Medical Care Associated with Increased Health Care Costs Among the U.S. Heart Failure Population,” Journal of the American College of Cardiology Heart Failure S2213-1779, no. 21, published online Aug. 11, 2021.
  5. See Roosa Tikkanen et al. (eds.), International Health Care System Profiles (Commonwealth Fund, Dec. 2020).
  6. Amber Willink, Cathy Schoen, and Karen Davis, “Dental Care and Medicare Beneficiaries: Access Gaps, Cost Burdens, and Policy Options,” Health Affairs 35, no. 12 (Dec. 2016): 2241–48.
  7. D. Petrovic et al., “The Determinants and Consequences of Forgoing Healthcare,” European Journal of Public Health 30, Suppl. 5 (Sept. 2020); Amanda Elise Lechner, Forgoing Medical Care Due to Costs: The Causal Effect of Health Care Burdens on Health, DigitalGeorgetown, Georgetown University Institutional Repository, Apr. 15, 2011.
  8. Willink et al., “Dental Care and Medicare Beneficiaries,” 2016.

Publication Details

Date

Contact

Gretchen Jacobson, Vice President, Medicare, The Commonwealth Fund

[email protected]

Citation

Gretchen Jacobson et al., When Costs Are a Barrier to Getting Health Care: Reports from Older Adults in the United States and Other High-Income Countries (Commonwealth Fund, Oct. 2021). https://doi.org/10.26099/m7jm-2n91